Showing posts with label disclaimer (undisclosed). Show all posts
Showing posts with label disclaimer (undisclosed). Show all posts

Tuesday, 18 December 2018

G 0001/03 - "Undisclosed" disclaimers - #4

Citation rank: 4
No. of citations: 308

G 1/03 (together with G 2/03) defined under which conditions "undisclosed disclaimers" (i.e., disclaimers disclaiming subject matter where neither the disclaimer nor the subject-matter excluded by it have a basis in the application as filed) can be introduced into a claim without extending subject matter under Art. 123(2).

Prior to G 1/03 established case law allowed - under certain circumstances - disclaimers having no basis in the application as filed. This case law had been called into question in T 323/97, which held that the introduction of a negative feature into a claim resulting in the exclusion of certain embodiments was, regardless of the name "disclaimer", nonetheless an amendment governed by Article 123(2) and (3) EPC.

In particular the chemical industry had often relied on undisclosed disclaimers to establish novelty of their broad Markush-type claims over prior art that they had previously been unaware of; be it because the prior art was post-published under Art. 54(3), or be it because the prior art document was "accidental", e.g., from a far remote technical field.

The Enlarged Board looked into the situation concerning post-published Art. 54(3) documents. Considering the legislative history of Art. 54(3) they noted that the fathers of the EPC opted for the more restrictive "whole contents approach" rather than for the less stringent "prior claim approach", under which "hole contents approach" the whole content of a post-published 54(4) document is taken into account, rather than only its claims (point 2.1.1 of the reasons). They considered that the legislator tried to limit the detrimental effect of post-published 54(3) documents by making them only relevant with respect to novelty, not relevant with respect to inventive step (Art. 56, second sentence).

In line with this approach of limiting the negative effect of post-published prior art on subsequent patent applications (and patents), the Enlarged Board allowed the disclaiming of parts of the originally claimed scope, if the excluded subject matter was disclosed in a 54(3) document. This was justified as follows:
"Such a disclaimer, only excluding subject-matter for legal reasons, is required to give effect to Article 54(3) EPC and has no bearing on the technical information in the application. It is, therefore, not in contradiction to Article 123(2) EPC. Applied in this sense, the term disclaimer is justified also in its literal meaning. An invention comprising different specific embodiments or groups thereof has been disclosed in the application as filed, a part of which is excluded from the requested protection, ie no longer claimed. The remaining subject-matter is not modified by the disclaimer." (point 2.1.3 of the reasons)
For related reasons, the Enlarged Board also found it appropriate to allow undisclosed disclaimers in the case of "accidental anticipations" (an anticipation is accidental if it is so unrelated to and remote from the claimed invention that the person skilled in the art would never have taken it into consideration when making the invention, see Headnote II.1). Since the applicant could not have been aware of the accidentally anticipating document, it would be appropriate to allow him to disclaim the accidentally disclosed subject matter, so as to make his claim new over the accidentally anticipating document (point 2.2 of the reasons).

Finally, the Enlarged Board found it appropriate to also allow undisclosed disclaimers in cases where a claim includes subject matter which is excluded from patentability under Art. 52-57 for non-technical reasons. The reasoning here was that a foreign applicant, who files a first application in his country (where certain subject matter, such as medical methods, is possibly not excluded from patentability) cannot be expected to know or to study the substantive patentability requirements of all countries in which he/she may later wish to claim the priority of his first application. The Enlarged Board stated:
"... the applicant cannot be expected to check the substantive patent law of all possible states before filing the application and to introduce appropriate limitations in order to cope with any exclusions which he might later face in the respective states. Extending the requirement of sufficient disclosure to limitations merely disclaiming subject-matter not eligible for patent protection would seriously impede the long-established systems of obtaining patent protection in an international framework." (point 2.4.3 of the reasons)
The Enlarged Board went on to defined the manner in which undisclosed disclaimers must be formulated. They stated that a disclaimer must not remove more than is necessary to restore novelty or to disclaim subject-matter excluded from patentability under Art. 52-57 for non-technical reasons (Headnote II.2). Furthermore, a undisclosed disclaimer must not become relevant for the assessment of inventive step or sufficiency of disclosure, because then it would infringe Art. 123(2) EPC (Headnote II.3). Finally, the amended claim containing the disclaimer must meet the requirements of clarity and conciseness of Article 84 EPC (Headnote II.4).

 Remark: G 1/03 established a stable set of rules regarding the admissibility of undisclosed disclaimers. This stable system was called into question later, when G 2/10 (dealing with so-called "disclosed disclaimers") was published. Some Boards of Appeal have interpreted G 2/10 in such a manner as to impose additional requirements on the admissibility of undisclosed disclaimers (i.e., on top of the requirements expressed in G 1/03). In particular, some Boards found that the "remaining subject matter test" of G 2/10 should also be applied to undisclosed disclaimers. However, G 1/16 recently re-established the old order by clarifying that the requirements expressed in G 1/03 are the only ones to be applied to undisclosed disclaimers.

 ---

Headnote:
I. An amendment to a claim by the introduction of a disclaimer may not be refused under Article 123(2) EPC for the sole reason that neither the disclaimer nor the subject-matter excluded by it from the scope of the claim have a basis in the application as filed.
II. The following criteria are to be applied for assessing the allowability of a disclaimer which is not disclosed in the application as filed:
II.1 A disclaimer may be allowable in order to:
- restore novelty by delimiting a claim against state of the art under Article 54(3) and (4) EPC;
- restore novelty by delimiting a claim against an accidental anticipation under Article 54(2) EPC; an anticipation is accidental if it is so unrelated to and remote from the claimed invention that the person skilled in the art would never have taken it into consideration when making the invention; and
- disclaim subject-matter which, under Articles 52 to 57 EPC, is excluded from patentability for non-technical reasons.
II.2 A disclaimer should not remove more than is necessary either to restore novelty or to disclaim subject-matter excluded from patentability for non-technical reasons.
II.3 A disclaimer which is or becomes relevant for the assessment of inventive step or sufficiency of disclosure adds subject-matter contrary to Article 123(2) EPC.
II.4 A claim containing a disclaimer must meet the requirements of clarity and conciseness of Article 84 EPC.
The full text of the decision can be found here.

Friday, 19 October 2018

G 0002/10 - "Disclosed" disclaimers - #25

Citation rank: 25
No. of citations: 145

G 2/10 is concerned with the question of whether and when "disclosed disclaimers" are allowed. Disclosed disclaimers are amendments by which certain embodiments, which are disclosed as embodiments of the invention, are excluded from the scope of a generically formulated claim. G 2/10 follows G 1/03 and G 2/03, which dealt with the admissibility of "non-disclosed" disclaimers, i.e., with the conditions under which disclaimers disclaiming subject matter which was not disclosed at all in the original application could be disclaimed.

In the underlying examination case, the applicant amended a claim to a catalytic DNA molecule having site-specific endonuclease activity specific for a nucleotide sequence. The definition of the claimed DNA molecule was generic, in that it allowed certain variations in the nucleotide sequence. The applicant amended the original claim by disclaiming from its scope certain sequences, which were originally disclosed as embodiments of the invention. Claim 1 of the Main request read:
"1. A catalytic DNA molecule having site-specific endonuclease activity [...] said molecule having the formula:
 [...]
... wherein the first substrate binding region does not have the sequence 5'-CTTTGGTTA-3' or 5'-CTAGTTA-3',
wherein the second substrate binding region does not have the sequence 5'-TTTTTCC 3'-and
wherein the said catalytic DNA molecule does not show site-specific endonuclease activity for the sequence: 5'–GGAAAAAGUAACUAGAGAUG-GAAG–3' (SEQ ID NO 135)."
Before G 2/10, it was common practice at the EPO to allow such disclaimers of embodiments, which were presented as part of the invention.

The Enlarged Board, however, considered that there was no reason to generally allow such disclosed disclaimers, because the overriding principle for assessing the admissibility of amendments during prosecution was still Art. 123(2) EPC.

They considered that undisclosed disclaimers are not allowed, unless the subject matter remaining within the claim after the disclaimer can be directly and unambiguously be derived from the application as filed.

This test was later referred to as the "remaining subject matter test" of G 2/10.

---

Headnote:
The question referred to the Enlarged Board of Appeal is answered as follows:
1a. An amendment to a claim by the introduction of a disclaimer disclaiming from it subject-matter disclosed in the application as filed infringes Article 123(2) EPC if the subject-matter remaining in the claim after the introduction of the disclaimer is not, be it explicitly or implicitly, directly and unambiguously disclosed to the skilled person using common general knowledge, in the application as filed.
1b. Determining whether or not that is the case requires a technical assessment of the overall technical circumstances of the individual case under consideration, taking into account the nature and extent of the disclosure in the application as filed, the nature and extent of the disclaimed subject-matter and its relationship with the subject-matter remaining in the claim after the amendment.
 The full text of the decision can be found here.

Friday, 17 August 2018

G 0002/03- Disclaimer/PPG ("undisclosed" disclaimers) - #62

Citation rank: 62
No. of citations: 79

G 2/03 and G 1/03 both deal with similar questions relating to the admissibility of "undisclosed disclaimers", i.e., amendments excluding from a claim subject matter where neither the disclaimer nor the disclaimed subject matter were disclosed in the original application as filed. The text of both decisions is identical.

Before G 1/03 and G 2/03, undisclosed disclaimers had been widely accepted by the Technical Boards, although there was variation in the conditions and circumstances under which undisclosed disclaimers were allowed.

This practice had been fundamentally called into question by T 323/97, which treated disclaimers as any other amendment, and thus required that the undisclosed disclaimer must find basis in the original application as-filed (which is, by definition, never the case).

The referring decisions of G 1/03 and G 2/03 (T 507/99 and T 451/99) seeked clarification regarding the conditions and circumstances under which undisclosed disclaimers are to be admitted.

The Enlarged Board of Appeals considered various arguments advanced by the referring decisions, by the President of the EPO and by the public. The most far-reaching argument, according to which a disclaimer is nothing but a voluntary restriction of the claim, and therefore not a technical feature, which could thus not infringe Art. 123(2), was rejected. Any amendment to a claim was considered to have a technical meaning, otherwise the amendment would be useless.

1. Undisclosed disclaimers to establish novelty over Art. 54(3) prior art
The Enlarged Board went on to analyse the motivation of Technical Boards which had previously allowed undisclosed disclaimers to establish novelty over post-published prior art under Art. 54(3) (also called "prior rights"). The Enlarged Board considered that prior art under Art. 54(3) intrinsically poses a problem, because the applicant cannot know the content of such prior art, when he files his application. It would thus be somewhat unfair not to allow the applicant to react to the publication of the 54(3) document by excluding subject matter disclosed therein. The Enlarged Board also reviewed the manner in which the national patent systems dealt with "prior rights" (e.g., the "prior claim approach" vs. "whole contents approach") and noted that the EPC chose to use the stricter "whole contents approach", under which the whole content of the Art. 54(3) document could be held against the later application. In exchange, the applicant of the later application should be allowed some room to maneuver, in cases where such unexpected 54(3) documents showed up.

Taking various other aspects into account, the Enlarged Board finally found that undisclosed disclaimers establishing novelty over Art. 54(3) prior art are admissible, because the disclaimer is introduced for legal reasons only, and does not change the technical teaching (reasons 2.1.3).

2. Undisclosed disclaimers to avoid "accidental anticipation"
The Board also found it appropriate that undisclosed disclaimers are allowed, if the disclaimer served to save the claim from "accidental anticipation", i.e., from anticipation by a document which is, although novelty-destroying, so unrelated and remote from the claimed invention that the person skilled in the art would never have taken it into consideration when making the invention.

3. Undisclosed disclaimers to exclude subject matter excluded from patentability for non-technical reasons
A third group of circumstances under which the introduction of undisclosed disclaimers was held admissible covers cases, in which the claim covers subject matter excluded from patentablity for non-technical reasons, such as the medical methods of Art. 53(c), or inventions contrary to "ordre public" or morality of Art. 53(a). Also here, undisclosed disclaimers were allowed.

4. Futher conditions to be met for undisclosed disclaimers to be admissible
As further conditions to be met for an undisclosed disclaimer to be admissible, the Enlarged Board stated that the disclaimer should not remove more than necessary either to restore novelty or to disclaim subject-matter excluded from patentability for non-technical reasons.

The disclaimer must also not become relevant for the assessment of inventive step or sufficiency of disclosure. Otherwise it would obviously change the technical teaching of the application and thus add subject-matter contrary to Article 123(2) EPC.

The amended claim containing the disclaimer must be clear and concise, as required by Art. 84 EPC.

---

Headnote:
I. An amendment to a claim by the introduction of a disclaimer may not be refused under Article 123(2) EPC for the sole reason that neither the disclaimer nor the subject-matter excluded by it from the scope of the claim have a basis in the application as filed.
II. The following criteria are to be applied for assessing the allowability of a disclaimer which is not disclosed in the application as filed:
II.1 A disclaimer may be allowable in order to:
- restore novelty by delimiting a claim against state of the art under Article 54(3) and (4) EPC;
- restore novelty by delimiting a claim against an accidental anticipation under Article 54(2) EPC; an anticipation is accidental if it is so unrelated to and remote from the claimed invention that the person skilled in the art would never have taken it into consideration when making the invention; and
- disclaim subject-matter which, under Articles 52 to 57 EPC, is excluded from patentability for non-technical reasons.
II.2 A disclaimer should not remove more than is necessary either to restore novelty or to disclaim subject-matter excluded from patentability for non-technical reasons.
II.3 A disclaimer which is or becomes relevant for the assessment of inventive step or sufficiency of disclosure adds subject-matter contrary to Article 123(2) EPC.
II.4 A claim containing a disclaimer must meet the requirements of clarity and conciseness of Article 84 EPC.

Sunday, 8 July 2018

T 0170/87 - Undisclosed disclaimers (prior to G 1/03, G 2/10, G 1/16) - #94

Citation rank: 94
No. of citations: 56

Before the Enlarged Board of Appeals dealt with disclosed and undisclosed disclaimers in G 1/03, G 2/10 and G 1/16, T 170/87 was frequently cited for establishing that undisclosed disclaimers were in principle admissible to establish novelty over prior art, but they must not establish inventive step.

For example, T 159/95 cites T 170/87 as follows:
"According to the established jurisprudence of the Boards of Appeal, it may be permissible to exclude a specific prior art from the claimed subject-matter by means of a disclaimer, even if the original application provides no basis for such an exclusion (see decisions T 170/87, OJ EPO 1989, 441, point 8.4.1 of the reasons; [...])"
Clearly, T 170/87 lost most of its significance when G 1/03 (at least up until G 2/10) clarified the situation around undisclosed disclaimers. This explains the steep drop in citations after G 1/03 came out. Today, of course, G 1/03 and G 1/16 should be referred to regarding admissibility of undisclosed disclaimers.

---

Headnote:
1. A figure which serves only to give a schematic explanation of the principle of the subject-matter of the patent and not to represent it in every detail does not allow the sure conclusion that the disclosed teaching purposively excludes a feature not represented. Such a "negative" feature (here: "with no internal fittings") may not subsequently be incorporated into the claim.
2. A disclaimer can be used to make an inventive teaching which overlaps with the state of the art novel but it cannot make an obvious teaching inventive.
 The full text of the decision can be accessed here.