Showing posts with label level of proof. Show all posts
Showing posts with label level of proof. Show all posts

Wednesday, 5 September 2018

T 0270/90 - Public prior use / Ballance of propabilities - #49

Citation rank: 49
No. of citations: 94

T 270/90 is a further decision within the 100 most-cited EPO Board of Appeals decsions, which deals with the required level of proof in public prior use cases.

The instant case T 270/90 is earlier than T 472/92 (which was recently commentated in this blog here) and the latter makes reference to the present case. The underlying cases, however, are slightly different, and therefore the later T 472/92 comes to a different conclusion regarding the required level of proof. The two decisions, however, do not contradict each other.

In the present case T 270/90 the appellant/proprietor argued strongly that, as a matter of law, the issue of public prior use needed to be proved more strictly than any of the other grounds of objection available under Article 100 EPC.

The Board disagreed. Regarding the principles of law that apply to appeal proceedings under the EPC, the Board stated:
"When arriving at their decisions, the Boards, in addition to exercising their inquisitorial powers (should this be necessary), decide the issues before them on the basis of the evidence adduced by the parties. Their decision need not, and indeed in most cases could not, be based on absolute conviction, but has, instead, to be arrived at on the basis of the overall balance of probability, in other words, on the footing that one set of facts is more likely to be true than the other (see decision T 182/89 of 14 December 1989, Extent of opposition/SUMITOMO, OJ EPO 1991, 391).
These principles clearly apply to all facts and matters alleged in relation to all grounds of opposition, including public prior use. Accordingly, the appellant's submission that the evidential test or burden of proof for prior public use needs to be stricter than that for other grounds of objection under the EPC is rejected." (point 2.1 of the reasons)
In the case at hand, the decisive question was whether certain products - which were delivered from the patent proprietor to the opponent before the date of filing of the patent in dispute - were delivered under a (tacit) confidentiality agreement or whether the delivery was under the terms of "general commercial use". This question was answered by the Board using the general ballance-of-propability standard, i.e., the Board simply considered, which set of facts presented by the parties was more likely to be true.

The Board decided that it was indeed more likely that the delivered products were already freely available on the market, and therefore the public-prior-use attack succeeded.

Comment: The above situation, i.e., a situation in which both parties have more or less the same access to the relevant evidence regarding an alleged public prior use, is rather unusual. Normally, the party alleging the prior use has power over most or all relevant evidence, whereas the proprietor is left to point to gaps or inconsistencies in the argumentation of the opponent. Under such (normal) circumstances T 472/92 decided that the more strict standard "up to the hilt" must be applied. See: here.

---

Headnote:
In opposition proceedings decisions of the Boards on the evidence adduced by the parties must be arrived at on the basis of the overall balance of probability, as distinct from "beyond all reasonable doubt" or "absolute conviction". Each of the parties must therefore seek to prove facts alleged by it to that degree of proof.
The full text of the decision can be found here. 

Monday, 3 September 2018

T 0472/92 - Public prior use / Level of proof "up to the hilt"- #51

Citation rank: 51
No. of citations: 92

This appeal case concerns alleged public prior use. In the underlying case, the Opposition Division rejected an opposition based entirely on public prior use attacks. The opponent appealed. The Technical Board of Appeals then had to evaluate, i.a., the evidence presented in support of the alleged public prior use.

The Board referred to an earlier decision, T 270/90, which also concerned public prior use. In T 270/90, the Board used the same standard of proof as is normally applied with any other objection under Article 100 EPC, namely the "balance of probability". T 270/90, however, concerned a case of public prior use, in which both parties had more or less the same access to the evidence relating to the public prior use. With regard to T 270/90, the Board in T 472/92 stated:
"[...] In that case [T 270/90], the Board expressly refused to accept a submission that the much more rigorous standard of "beyond all reasonable doubt" should apply, even if, as was the case there, both parties were able to access and to adduce evidence relating to the decisive issue of confidentiality of the transactions alleged to constitute prior public use." (point 3.1 of the reasons)
The Board in T 472/92 reaffirmed the approach of T 270/90 for cases in which both parties have access to the relevant evidence. The Board, however, remarked:
"[...] in the majority of prior public use cases practically all the evidence in support of an alleged prior public use lies within the power and knowledge of the opponent, so the patentee seldom has any ready, or indeed any access to it at all. All he can, in practice, do is to challenge that evidence by pointing out any inconsistencies contained in it or to draw attention to any gaps in the chain of commercial transactions that needs to be established by the opponent in order to succeed on this ground." (point 3.1 of the reasons)
The Board found that, in such cases where all evidence is in the hands of the opponent,
"... the opponent must prove his case up to the hilt, for little if any evidence will be available to the patentee to establish the contradictory proposition that no prior public use had taken place"(still point 3.1 of the reasons, emphasis added)
Regarding the manner in which public prior use must be proven "up to the hilt", the Board stated that the following facts must be proven:

   (a) the date on which the prior use occurred ("when" issue),
   (b) exactly what was in prior use ("what" issue), and
   (c) the circumstances surrounding the prior use (e.g., issue of confidentiality).

These criteria are nowadays regularly applied by Examination/Opposition Divisions and Appeal Boards in public prior use cases. They also entered into the Guidelines, currently at: G-IV, 7.2.

In the case at hands, the opponent-appellant failed to prove, i.a., that an alleged delivery of products falling under the claims, from the opponent to a joint-venture partner of the opponent, was not under a confidentiality agreement (see "(c)", above).

For this reason alone, the Board concluded that the public prior use attack had to fail.

---

Headnote I:
Although the standard of proof is the same for all objections covered by Article 100 EPC (cf. T 270/90, OJ EPO 93, 725), in those prior public use cases, where practically all the evidence in support of an alleged prior public use lies within the power and knowledge of the Opponent, the latter has to prove his case up to the hilt (Reasons 3.1).
The full text of the decision can be found here.