Showing posts with label problem-solution approach. Show all posts
Showing posts with label problem-solution approach. Show all posts

Friday, 23 November 2018

T 0002/83 - Problem-inventions / The "could-would" approach - #11

Citation rank: 11
No. of citations: 216

T 2/83 is known for two things: firstly, it confirmed that "problem inventions" exist, i.e., inventions that are based on the finding of a previously unrecognised technical problem, and which inventions involve an inventive step even though the solution to the problem appears obvious once the technical problem is formulated (Headnote I). Secondly, T 2/83 created the so-called "could-would" approach, which approach is used in the final step of the problem-solution approach, namely in the assessment of whether the solution to a technical problem proposed by a patent claim is obvious in view of the prior art.

Claim 1 under dispute related to a tablet containing simethicone and an antacid, the tablet comprising a first volume portion containing the simethicone on a solid carrier and a second volume portion containing said antacid. The claim further defined that the tablet had "barrier means" between the first and second volume portions for maintaining the simethicone in the first volume portion and out of contact with the antacid in the second volume portion, and for preventing migration of ingredients from one volume portion to another.

The applicant argued that, although it was known that simethicone may be readily released when adsorbed on a lactose filler material, its release turned out to be retarded or prevented when the material is contiguous to the antacid component. It appeared that simethicone migrates, against all expectations, from the adsorbed state into the solid antacid layer and becomes absorbed therein. Once this unknown problem has been discovered, the claimed solution (i.e., providing "barrier means" to prevent migration of components from one volume portion to another) was trivial.

The Board generally agreed. They confirmed that
"[t]he discovery of a yet unrecognised problem may, in certain circumstances, give rise to patentable subject- matter in spite of the fact that the claimed solution is retrospectively trivial and in itself obvious ("problem inventions")." (point 6 of the reasons)
They also agreed that the problem of migration of semeticone from one volume portion of the tablet to another was previously unrecognised. Regarding the question of whether the proposed solution to the technical problem proposed by the invention was obvious, the Board stated:
"The question regarding the inventive step, in relation to the modification of the layered tablet of the state of the art as suggested by the present applicants, is not whether the skilled man could have inserted a barrier between the layers but whether he would have done so in expectation of some improvement or advantage." (point 7 of the reasons; emphasis added)
In view of the fact that, in the underlying case, the problem of migration between volume portions of the tablet was previously not recognised as a problem, the skilled person could have introduced a barrier layer, but he did not have an incitement to do so. Hence, while the skilled person could have introduced the barrier layer, he would not necessarily have done so.

The Board concluded that claim 1 was based on inventive step.

The "could-would" approach is nowadays routinely applied in the assessment of inventive step by all instances of the EPO (see, e.g., Guidelines 2018, VII, 5.3).

---

Headnote:
I. The discovery of an unrecognised problem may in certain circumstances give rise to patentable subject-matter in spite of the fact that the claimed solution is retrospectively trivial and in itself obvious ("problem-inventions").
II. In a case where the applicant had supplemented a known layered tablet by the provision of a barrier between the layers, the Board held that the proper question to be asked was not whether the skilled man could have provided the barrier but whether he would have done so in expectation of some improvement or advantage.
The full text of the decision can be found here.

Thursday, 30 August 2018

T 0248/85 - Product by process claims / Selection of closest prior art - #53

Citation rank: 53
No. of citations: 88

T 248/85 dealt with two issues: Fistly, it commented on the question of novelty and inventive step of product-by-process claims. Secondly, it considered how the closest prior art is to be selected under the problem-solution approach.

1. Product-by-process claims
Claim 1 in the underlying examination case was directed to "[a] method of radiation processing a product made at least in part from [...]". Claims 4 and 5 were directed to "[Irradiated products] characterised in that it was actually made by and is the direct product of the process claimed in any one of Claim 2 or Claim 3". The Examining Division held method steps 1-3 allowable, but refused the product-by-process claims (4 and 5).

The applicant appealed and requested that the decision regarding the product-by-process claims be reviewed.

T 248/85 recalled that in the earlier case T 150/82, the Board already decided that product-by-process claims are admissible only if the products themselves fulfil the requirements for patentability and there is no other information available in the application which could enable the applicant to define the product satisfactorily by reference to its composition, structure or other testable parameter (T 248/85, point 3 of the reasons).

They also observed that in the present case, the applicant apparently had tried to circumvent this interpretation by using wording borrowed from Art. 64(2) EPC, namely by requiring that the product is a "direct product" of the process defined in the process claims. Concerning the novelty of the product so defined, the applicant admitted that the products claimed were not distinguishable from the products of the prior art, but they argued that novelty was conferred by the process of the relevant method claims.

The Board did not accept this interpretation. T 150/82 was strictly applied to the instant claim wording. The product-by-process claims were thus considered non-novel.

2. Closest prior art / inventive step
As briefly mentioned above, the decision of the Examining Division (ED) found that method claims 1-3 were new and inventive; only product-by-process claims 4 and 5 lacked novelty. The appellant thus requested that only claims 4 and 5 be reviewed. In the event that the Appeal Board confirmed the ED's decision, the appellant requested that a patent be granted on the basis of method claims 1-3.

The Board decided otherwise. Firstly, they confirmed the ED's finding that the product-by-process claims were not novel. However, instead of granting a patent on the method claims 1-3 they reviewed the ED's decision regarding inventive step of claims 1-3. They observed that the ED simply accepted the state of the art mentioned in the description to be closest prior art, without even looking at the documents in detail, and without establishing which problem was solved by the distinguishing features of the invention over that prior art. The Board stated that it is necessary to define the problem underlying the alleged invention by comparison of the technical results achieved by the claimed invention with those achieved by the designated closest state of the art (point 11 of the reasons).
The Board therefore concluded that the problem-solution approach applied by the ED was flawed and remitted the case back to first instance for (proper) examination of method claims 1-3.

---

Headnote:
1. The provisions of the EPC governing the requirements for patentability and those relating to the extent of protection fulfil different functions. A claim directed to subject-matter which, though coming within the extent of protection provided by the EPC, does not meet the requirements for patentability laid down in Articles 52 to 57, is not allowable. A known product is not rendered novel merely by means of further definition (as a "product of process").
2. An objective assessment of inventive step starting from the closest prior art implies that the latter has been positively identified and considered.
The full text of the decision can be found here.

Monday, 27 August 2018

T 0176/84 - Prior art from a "neighboring technical field" - #56

Citation rank: 56
No. of citations: 85

T 176/84 was concerned with a decision from the examining division, which had refused an application claiming a hand-operatable pencil sharpener including a container to collect the shavings, enclosed to prevent egress of shavings, the containing having an aperture through which the pencil to be sharpened can be inserted, and the aperture is closed completely when the sharpener is not in use. The closing of the pencil sharpener was effected by a slider, which slider was pushed open by the pencil, when the pencil was inserted.

The state of the art included hand-operated pencil sharpener, which also included a slider to open and close the aperture, however, those sliders had to be opened manually, not automatically by insertion of the pencil.

The examining division, in the contested decision, considered that the claimed pencil sharpener lacked inventive step in view of a document disclosing a savings-box having an aperture, which was opened automatically when a coin was inserted into the box and then closed again. The examining division was of the opinion that the field of saving-boxes was sufficiently close to the field of pencil sharpeners for it to be taken into account, because both pencil sharpeners and savings boxes belonged to the "broader field of the closing of containers".

The Board in T 176/84 disagreed. They stated: 
5.3.1 While it is indeed perfectly reasonable to expect a person skilled in the art if need be, i.e. in the absence of useful suggestions in the relevant field as to how a given problem might be solved, to look for suitable parallels in neighbouring fields, the question of what is a neighbouring field is one of fact and the solution depends, in the opinion of the Board, on whether the fields are so closely related that the person skilled in the art seeking a solution to a given problem would take into account developments in the neighbouring field. It is furthermore quite reasonable to expect a skilled person to refer to the state of the art in the general field of technology in which the same problems or problems similar to those in the special field of the application extensively arise and of which a person skilled in the art must be expected to be aware.

5.3.2 In the present case, even adopting the same premise as the Examining Division that the person skilled in the art by abstracting the problem would eventually, in his search for suggestions as to how he might solve the problem underlying the application, turn to the broader, that is to say general field of container closing, while he would then have entered what the Examining Division considers to be the generic field, he would not have reached the field of securing mechanisms for savings-box slots. In view of the technological differences between the two fields - storage of coins in a container as opposed to sharpening of pencils with provision for collection of shavings - there is no reason why it should occur to a skilled person to refer to this specific area - which the Examining Division considers to be part of the same broader field - to see how similar problems had been solved there.
The Board concluded that the claimed pencil sharpener was inventive.

---

Headnote:
The state of the art to be considered when examining for inventive step includes, as well as that in the specific field of the application, the state of any relevant art in neighbouring fields and/or a broader general field of which the specific field is part, that is to say any field in which the same problem or one similar to it arises and of which the person skilled in the art of the specific field must be expected to be aware.
The full text of the decision can be found here.

Thursday, 23 August 2018

T 0229/85 - Objective technical problem / no pointers to the solution - #58

Citation rank: 58
No. of citations: 84

T 229/85 dealt with an important aspect of the problem-solution approach, namely with the question of how to formulate the objective technical problem.


As already mentioned here in this blog, the problem-and-solution approach, normally includes three stages:
(i) determining the "closest prior art",

(ii) establishing the "objective technical problem" to be solved, and
(iii) considering whether or not the claimed invention, starting from the closest prior art and the objective technical problem, would have been obvious to the skilled person (GL 2017, G-VII, 5).

T 229/85 was is concerned with step (ii).

In the underlying decision, the examining division had refused the application for lacking inventive step. The invention concerned an etching process in which metal, such as copper, is etched from printed circuits by means of a solution containing sulphuric or phosphoric acid and hydrogen peroxide, and the etching solution is recycled. A problem occurring in the prior art processes was that the hydrogen peroxide decomposed through catalytic action of the etched/dissolved metal, mostly during recycling. Hydrogen peroxide therefore had to be added in relatively large amounts. The prior art used "stabilisers" to neutralise the dissolved metal ions, thereby reducing the amount of hydrogen peroxide that had to be added during the process. The invention proposed adding the hydrogen peroxide such that the "quantity of hydrogen peroxide [is] just sufficient for a single etching operation [and] is added to the solution immediately before or at the moment that the solution is applied to the circuit board it is desired to etch and that when the etching process is completed practically no hydrogen peroxide remains in the solution" (characterising feature of claim 1). Because the decomposition of the hydrogen peroxide (in particular during recycling) is reduced, the inventive process did not need (and use) any stabilisers in the etching solution.

The examining division formulated the technical problem as lying in the provision of a process that prevented the decomposition of hydrogen peroxide without using stabilisers. The Board, however, found that this definition of the problem was influenced by the information contained in the present application, and therefore inadmissibly incorporated part of the solution offered by the invention.

The Board stated:
"The idea of doing away with stabilisers is an essential part of the teaching of the invention as reflected in the solution given above and ultimately consisting in regulating the amount of hydrogen peroxide added to the solution and its timing. However, the technical problem addressed by an invention must be so formulated as not to contain pointers to the solution, since including part of a solution offered by an invention in the statement of the problem must, when the state of the art is assessed in terms of that problem, necessarily result in an ex post facto view being taken of inventive activity. For this reason alone the decision of the Examining Division cannot stand." (point 5 of the reasons)
 For that reason, the Board decided that the decision of the examining division was set aside and the matter was referred back to first instance for a patent to be granted on the basis of the application as originally filed.


---

Headnote:
The technical problem to be solved by an invention must be so formulated as not to contain pointers to the solution.
The full text of the decision can be found here.

Monday, 13 August 2018

T 0024/81 - The problem-solution-approach - #66

Citation rank: 66
No. of citations: 73

T 24/81 is one of the landmark decisions, on which the problem-solution-approach for the assessment of inventive step is based.

The problem-solution-approach was developed by the Boards of Appeals to make the assessment of inventive step as objective as possible. For example, the approach is based on an "objective technical problem", which results from the technical effect that the distinguishing features add to the closest prior art.

According to the current Guidelines (2017, G-VII, 5), the problem-and-solution approach, includes three main stages:

(i) determining the "closest prior art",
(ii) establishing the "objective technical problem" to be solved, and
(iii) considering whether or not the claimed invention, starting from the closest prior art and the objective technical problem, would have been obvious to the skilled person.

Correct application of the problem and solution approach avoids this inadmissible ex post facto analysis which draws on knowledge of the invention (T 24/81).

The EPO's Case Law Book, at least for inventions in the chemical field (I.D.9.8.1), mentions further steps in the problem-solution-approach. The steps to be followed according to the CLB are:

a) establishing the closest prior art
b) defining the problem in the light of that prior art
c) identifying the solution
d) demonstrating the success of the solution
e) optionally reformulating the problem
f) examining the obviousness of the solution in view of the state of the art

In the additional step d) it is verified that the distinguishing features indeed solve the objective technical problem, and if not, the problem is re-formulated in step e), often in a less ambitious manner, e.g., as providing a mere "alternative" to what is described in the closest prior art.

---

Headnotes:
I. Objectivity in the assessment of inventive step is achieved by starting out from the objectively ruling state of the art, in the light of which the technical problem is determined which the invention addresses and solves from an objective point of view, and consideration is given to the question of the obviousness of the disclosed solution to this problem as seen by the man skilled in the art and having those capabilities which can be objectively expected of him. In contrast a mere investigation for indications of the presence of inventive step is no substitute for the technically skilled assessment of the invention vis-a-vis the state of the art, pursuant to Article 56 EPC. Where such indications are present, the overall picture of the state of the art and consideration of all significant factors may show that inventive step is involved, but will not necessarily do so. A process developed in the light of a need which arose relatively shortly before the application is not deemed to involve inventive step if this need could be readily met by an obvious combination of teachings from the state of the art.
II. When examining for inventive step, the state of the art must be assessed from the point of view of the man skilled in the art at the time of priority relevant for the application. Consequently all previously published embodiments must be taken into consideration which offered a suggestion to the skilled practitioner for solving the problem addressed, even where those embodiments were not particularly emphasised.
The full text of the decsion can be accessed here.