Showing posts with label revocation on request of the proprietor. Show all posts
Showing posts with label revocation on request of the proprietor. Show all posts

Tuesday, 30 October 2018

T 0073/84 - Revocation by the patent proprietor - #20

Citation rank: 20
No. of citations: 162

It is not foreseen in opposition and opposition-appeals procedures that the patentee requests revocation of his own patent. For example, such an outcome is not among the possible outcomes of an opposition division listed in Art. 101(2) and (3). The possibility for the proprietor of a European patent to request revocation of its own patent was only added to the EPC2000 through the limitation or revocation procedure according to Art. 105a-105c.

In the opposition case underlying T 73/84, the Opposition Division had rejected the opposition and the patent was maintained unamended. The opponent appealed against this decision. At that stage, the patent proprietor referred to Legal Advice No. 11/82 (OJ (EPO) 2/1982, p. 57) and stated that, in order to terminate the appeal proceedings, he no longer approved the text in which the patent was granted and would not be submitting an amended text. Legal Advice 11/82 stated that in opposition proceedings, if  the applicant states that he no longer approves the text in which the patent was granted and does not submit an amended text, the patent must be revoked.

The Board noted with respect to the same situation in appeal proceedings that:
3. Since the text of the patent is at the disposition of the patent proprietor, a patent cannot be maintained against the proprietor's will. If the patent proprietor withdraws his approval, expressed before the first instance, of the text of the patent as granted and declares that he will not be submitting an amended text, it may be inferred that he wishes to prevent any text whatever of the patent from being maintained.
4. However, the patent proprietor cannot terminate the proceedings by telling the EPO that he is surrendering the European Patent, since this is not provided for in the Convention. Thus he would only be able, as far as national law permitted, to surrender the patent vis-à-vis the national patent offices of the designated Contracting States under the relevant national law.
5. At the same time, the proceedings ought to be terminated as quickly as possible in the interests of legal certainty, which calls for a clarification of the industrial rights situation. The only possibility in such a case is to revoke the patent, as envisaged for other reasons in Article 102 EPC. The practice followed by the Opposition Divisions is thus confirmed.
Since then, withdrawal by the proprietor of his consent to the currently pending text (or texts) in appeal proceedings is used to terminate the appeal proceedings by revocation of the patent.

---

Headnote:
If the proprietor of a European patent states in opposition or appeal proceedings that he no longer approves the text in which the patent was granted and will not be submitting an amended text, the patent is to be revoked.
The full text of the decision can be found here.

See T 186/84 on the same issue in opposition proceedings.

Wednesday, 8 August 2018

T 0237/86 - Abandonment of patent in appeal - #69

Citation rank: 69
No. of citations: 72

T 237/86 deals with the question of how a patent proprietor can properly request the revocation of his patent in opposition appeal proceedings. The difficulty had been that abandonment of the patent was not expressly foreseen in the then current EPC1973, and is still not expressly mentioned in e.g. Art. 101 EPC (which only mentions the possibility of revoking the patent for the case that it does not meet the requirements of the  EPC).

At the time of T 237/86 it had already been common practice that a proprietor, who wished his patent to be revoked in opposition(-appeal) proceedings, withdrew his approval of the text of the patent. The patent was then revoked in view of Art. 113(2) EPC, which requires that the proprietor agrees to any text upheld by the opposition division. Alternatively, it was accepted that the patent proprietor directly requests revocation of his patent.

In T 237/86 the proprietor stated in writing: "We herewith abandon the above patent". The Registrar of the Board was of the opinion that abandonment of the patent in the course of opposition-appeal proceedings was not possible and he invited the proprietor to either withdraw his consent to the text of the patent upheld by the opposition division, or to request revocation of the patent, which the opponent did. The Registrar cited T 73/84, which states that "the patent proprietor cannot terminate the (opposition) proceedings by telling the EPO that he is surrendering the European patent, since this is not provided for in the Convention".

The Board in T 237/86, upon reviewing the communication of the Registrar found that a direct request for revocation sufficed, whatever the form of the words, when it was made clear to the boards that appellant and respondent agreed that the patent should be revoked. They said:
"When, as in the present case, it is made quite clear to the Board of Appeal (whatever the exact form of wording used) that both the Appellant and the Respondent are agreed that the patent should be revoked, the Board sees no difficulty in exercising its powers under Article 111(1) EPC, by deciding to revoke the patent." (point 2 of the reasons)
"Abandonment of the patent" was thus to be interpreted as a request to revoke the patent.

T 237/86 is most often cited for holding that an opposition division or Board can/must revoke the patent as soon as it is clear that the proprietor wishes the patent to be revoked. A statement to that effect must be considered equivalent to a request that the patent be revoked (see, e.g., T 626/86).

The issue of requesting revocation in opposition or appeal proceedings was devoted a chapter in the EPO's Case Law Book (chapter IV.C.5.2).

---

Headnote:
When it is made clear to the Board of Appeal, whatever the form of words used, that the Appellant and the Respondent are agreed that a patent should be revoked, the Board may exercise its power under Article 111(1) EPC to revoke the patent. The statement "We herewith abandon the above patent" sent to the Board of Appeal by the patent proprietor during the appeal stage of an opposition, is in this case equivalent to a request that the patent be revoked.
The full text of the decision can be found here.