Showing posts with label late filed evidence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label late filed evidence. Show all posts

Tuesday, 27 November 2018

T 1002/92 - Admissibility of late-filed evidence (in opposition and appeal) - #10

Citation rank: 10
No. of citations: 218

T 1002/92 deals with the issue of late-filing of evidence, in particular late-filed documents.

In this case, the opponent appealed against the decision of the Opposition Division rejecting his opposition (which was based on Art. 100(a), Art. 52(2)(c), schemes, rules or methods for doing business, and Art. 56).

Claim 1 related to a "System for determining the queue sequence for serving customers" in a telephone system. During the proceedings before the Opposition Division, the opponent attempted unsuccessfully to introduce evidence concerning prior use of Ericson's "Triton" telephone system, more than two years after the grant of the opposed European patent.

In the annex to the summons to oral proceedings, the Board expressed its preliminary view, that the subject-matter of claim 1 was a technical system with co-operating technical components, in which the operation of the computing means solves a technical problem. It was thus regarded patentable under Art. 52(1). They also stated that that the documents files after expiry of the opposition period appeared to have no influence on the decision to be taken, and might therefore be regarded as inadmissible under Article 114(2) EPC. In response the appellant filed  further evidence.

During the oral proceedings the opponent argued again that the late-filed evidence should be admitted. The Board used the opportunity to clarify the principles that apply when assessing whether late-filed evidence is to be admitted or not. They noted that Art. 99(1), R. 55(c) EPC1973  (now R. 76(c) EPC) not only required that the Notice of Opposition includes
(i) the extent to which the European patent is opposed; and
(ii) the grounds on which the opposition is based; but also:
(iii) an indication of the facts, evidence and arguments in support of these grounds.
The Board quoted the Enlarged Board of Appeal in G 9/91 and G 10/91 where it is said that:
"Rule 55 (c) EPC only makes sense interpreted as having the double function of governing (together with the other provisions) the admissibility of the opposition and of establishing at the same time the legal and factual framework, within which the substantive examination of the opposition in principle shall be conducted" (G 9/91, point 6 of the reasons)
While G 9/91 and G 10/91 were mainly concerned with the admissibility of late-filed grounds for opposition (and held that late-filed grounds should only be admitted is prima facie relevant), the case under appeal in T 1002/92 was concerned with late-filed evidence. In this context, the Board stated:
"It would be illogical to have one criterion for the admissibility of late-filed new facts, evidence and arguments in combination with a fresh ground, and a different criterion for judging the admissibility of late-filed new facts, evidence and arguments in support of a ground of opposition already covered by the opposition statement." (T 1002/93, point 3.2 of the reasons).
The Board finally concluded:
"Thus following the principles set out in opinion G 10/91, as regards proceedings before the opposition divisions, late- filed facts, evidence and related arguments, which go beyond the "indication of the facts, evidence and arguments" presented in the notice of opposition pursuant to Rule 55(c) EPC in support of the grounds of opposition on which the opposition is based, should only exceptionally be admitted into the proceedings by the opposition division if, prima facie, there are clear reasons to suspect that such late-filed material would prejudice the maintenance of the European patent in suit." (T 1002/92, point 3.3 of the reasons)
Regarding the proceedings before the Appeal Boards, T 1002/92 took an even stricter standpoint. They stated that - following the same principles, above -, the 
"'indication of the facts, evidence and arguments' presented in the notice of opposition in support of the grounds of opposition on which the opposition is based, should only very exceptionally be admitted into the [Appeal] proceedings, if such new material is prima facie highly relevant in the sense that it is highly likely to prejudice maintenance of the European patent in suit." (point 3.4 of the reasons; underling added)
Regarding the late-filed evidence in the case at hands, the Board found that it was not sufficiently relevant to be admitted at the late stage in the proceedings.

The evidence was hence not admitted.

---

Headnote:
1. In proceedings before the opposition divisions, late-filed facts, evidence and related arguments, which go beyond the "indication of the facts, evidence and arguments" presented in the notice of opposition pursuant to Rule 55(c) EPC in support of the grounds of opposition on which the opposition is based, should only exceptionally be admitted into the proceedings if prima facie, there are clear reasons to suspect that such late-filed material would prejudice the maintenance of the European patent.
2. In proceedings before the boards of appeal, new facts, evidence and related arguments, which go beyond the "indication of facts, evidence and arguments" presented in the notice of opposition pursuant to Rule 55(c) EPC in support of the grounds of opposition on which the opposition is based, should only very exceptionally be admitted into the proceedings in the appropriate exercise of the board's discretion, if such new material is prima facie highly relevant in the sense that it can reasonably be expected to change the eventual result and is thus highly likely to prejudice maintenance of the European patent; and having regard also to other relevant factors in the case, in particular whether the patentee objects to the admissibility of the new material and the reasons for any such objection, and the degree of procedural complication that its admission is likely to cause.
The full text of the decision can be found here.

Wednesday, 15 August 2018

T 0156/84 - Ex officio examination - #64

Citation rank: 64
No. of citations: 78


T 156/84 dealt with the principle mentioned in Art. 114(1) EPC that the EPO examines the facts of the case "of its own motion" (ex officio examination), and its conflict with Art. 114(2) EPC allowing the EPO to disregard late-filed facts and evidence.

In the underlying opposition case, the opposition division (OD) had disregarded documents D4 and D5, solely because they were filed after expiry of the 9 months opposition period. The OD justified the non-admittance of the documents into the procedure by stating that the nine-month period was sufficiently long and the two citations had been publicly available for a long time, as a matter of fact since 1933 and 1978 respectively.

The Board found that this conduct was not proper, taking into account the principles expressed in Art. 114(1) EPC. The Board stated:
"The Board considers that the principle of examination by the Office of its own motion enshrined in Article 114(1) EPC takes precedence over the possibility of disregarding facts or evidence not submitted in due time provided for in Article 114(2) EPC. This is evident from the wording of both provisions. That of Article 114(1) EPC: "ermittelt" in the German text, "shall examine" in the English and "procède" in the French, expresses an obligation whereas Article 114(2) EPC implies a discretion - the German text choosing the words "braucht nicht zu berücksichtigen", the English text "may disregard" and the French "peut ne pas tenir compte". The wording alone thus makes it clear that the provision in paragraph 1 has priority over that in paragraph 2." (point 3.4 of the reasons)
This does not only apply to examination proceedings (which may be regarded as being "100% ex-officio") but also in inter partes opposition and appeal proceedings. The Board stated in this regard:
"Even in inter partes proceedings before the EPO, which is what opposition proceedings are, account must be taken not only of the interests of the parties involved; the EPO also has a duty vis-à-vis the public not to grant or maintain patents which it is convinced are not legally valid. This is the real reason for the introduction of the principle of examination by the Office of its own motion in Article 114(1) EPC " (point 3.5 of the reasons)
T 156/84 says that, in order to saveguard the interests of the public, an OD or Appeal Board cannot disregard late-filed documents for the sole reason that they are late filed. The OD and Boards have to examine objectively the relevance of the citation introduced late into the proceedings and have to communicate the results to the parties at least in its decision.

Since this was not done by the OD in the underlying case, the case was remitted to the OD for further examination, taking D4 and D5 into account.

Remark: T 156/84 is a rather early decision on the principle of ex officio examination. Nowadays, G 10/91 ("Examination of oppositions/appeals") should be referred to regarding the proper amount of ex officio examination in opposition and appeal proceedings at the EPO.

---

Headnotes:
1. The principle of examination by the EPO of its own motion (Article 114(1) EPC) takes precedence over the possibility of disregarding facts or evidence not submitted in due time. This follows from the EPO's duty vis-à-vis the public not to grant or maintain patents which it is convinced are not legally valid.
2. The EPO has to examine the relevance of citations introduced late into the proceedings and has to communicate the results to the parties at least in its decision. No final decision on the opposition can be taken until such an examination has been performed.
3. Late-filed documents can be designated as not material by the EPO without having to give detailed reasons as it does in the case of citations referred to in due time.
4. Late-filed documents are not deemed not to have been submitted in due time simply because they have not been submitted during the opposition period; if careful preparation of the opposition proceedings would have revealed the late-filed documents earlier, it is the opponent's task to set out the circumstances that prevented him from mentioning the documents earlier.
The full text of the decision can be accessed here.

Saturday, 21 July 2018

T 0326/87 - Late filing of evidence in opposition/appeal results in apportionment of costs - #83

Citation rank: 83
No. of citations: 61
 
T 326/87 was frequently cited in the years from its publication in 1990 to 2008. Then, it seems to have run out of fashion. It was not cited by other Boards from 2009 onwards.

The reasons for the loss of popularity are not immediately apparent. It deals with an issue of ever-increasing relevance: late filing of evidence in opposition/appeal proceedings. T 326/87 is still referred to in the introductory portion of the chapter on late-filing in opposition/appeal proceedings in the EPO Case Law Book (ed. 2016, IV.C.1.3).

In the opposition case underlying T 326/87 the opposition was initially rejected. One of the opponents/appellant filed - together with its Grounds of Appeal - a further prior art document in support of its inventive step arguments. The Board considered whether such late-filed evidence should be admitted into the procedure.

The Board stressed that parties to oppositon and appeal procedures have a general duty to present evidence at an early stage in the procedure. Boards and Opposition Divisions have the discretion not to admit late-filed evidence (reasons 2.1.2; Art. 114(2) EPC).

The Board stated that, if a late-filed document is sufficiently relevant for it to be admitted into the procedure, the case should normally be remitted - together with the new document - to the first instance (reasons 2.2).

The Board further held that the party that filed the evidence late should normally bear the additional costs incurred as a result of the late-filing, both its own costs and any additional cost incurred by the other party/parties (reasons 2.3).

In the specific case, the Board admitted the relevant late-filed document into the procedure. It found that the excuse presented by the opponent/appellant for filing the document late (the late-filed document being a patent document from the former GDR, and at the time not normally present in the available "manual search stock") was credible and acceptable. The Board nevertheless ordered that the opponent bears (only) 50% of the patentee's costs for the oral proceedings in appeal.

---

Headnote:
1. The public's as well as the parties' interests require that opposition proceedings should be speedily concluded. This requirement clearly extends to appeal proceedings as well. Article 99(1) and Rule 55(c) EPC, read in the light of Rule 66 EPC, seek to ensure this by requiring the full presentation in the Notice of Opposition of the case that a patentee needs to meet in order to keep his patent in force (see paragraph 2.1.1 of the Reasons for the Decision).
2. Matter, e.g. facts and evidence, submitted for the first time in appeal proceedings may be disregarded by the Boards of Appeal as a matter of discretion and pursuant to Article 114(2) EPC, which sets the legal limit upon the inquisitorial duties of the Board under Article 114(1) EPC (see paragraph 2.1.2 of the Reasons for the Decision).
3. If the evidential weight of late-filed documents in relation to those already in the case ("their relevance") warrants their admission into the proceedings, the case should normally be remitted to the first instance (Article 111(1) EPC), particularly if the late-filed material puts the maintenance of the patent at risk (see paragraph 2.2 of the Reasons for the Decision).
4. In such a case, costs between the parties should be apportioned under Article 104 and Rule 63(1) EPC, in such a way that the late-filing party should normally bear all the additional costs caused by his tardiness (see paragraph 2.3 of the Reasons for the Decision).
5. Costs should only be shared between the parties if there exist strong mitigating circumstances for the late filing of facts, evidence or other matter (see final sentence of paragraph 2.3 and paragraph 5 of the Reasons for the Decision).
The text of the decision is available here.